Cold weather running. No, your lungs won’t freeze…

icySince posting about cold weather running a couple of weeks ago, emails have flooded in (well OK, I’ve had two of them) from runners telling me that sub-zero running can actually make your lungs freeze.

Naturally, this was not welcome news to someone who gets his biggest kicks playing Icelandic roulette, a game of my own devising, which involves running along the beach wondering when I’ll next stray onto a stretch of completely smooth and invisible ice on top of the sand. It’s a tremendous game BTW. And if I ever get someone to video me in the act, the resulting YouTube video will doubtless be called ‘Bambi Goes to Casualty.’ But I digress…

Returning to the subject in hand, these emails certainly gave me pause for thought. Can sub-zero air really freeze your lungs? Time then, for a little on-line research, which brought both good news and bad news.

First the good news: medical opinion and several scientific studies have definitively proven that in temperatures as low as -50 Celsius, the human body retains the ability to warm air on its way to the lungs, ensuring that they won’t freeze. The exception to this rule, naturally, is that when you die of exposure, your lungs will indeed freeze. But only when you’ve been dead for a few hours, so that’s probably not your number one worry then.

The bad news though, is that there is a well documented case of a runner in the States who, while testing the theory about cold air freezing the lungs, actually received the first inklings of frostbite in his, well, his, er…well, let’s just say it was in an extremity that most chaps wouldn’t wish to lose anything off the length of and leave it there shall we?

For those of you who are now sitting cross-legged and whistling nervously, I feel duty-bound to relate that the tale had a happy ending. And possibly to also recall that a similar fate befell the late, great David Niven while skiing, when his pride and joy was saved by a swift immersion in a large brandy. No, really. It’s in the second of his autobiographies: ‘Bring on the Empty Horses.’ Which is very nearly as good a read as the first one, ‘The Moon’s a Balloon.’

Gosh, I really do seem to have gone slightly off topic don’t I? So, to get back to the point, no, running in cold air won’t cause your lungs to freeze. But if you find frozen air uncomfortable to run in, why not do what I do, and run with a Buff covering your mouth, which filters out quite a lot of the ice crystals before you can breathe them in.

Anyway, I’d love to stay and blog a bit more, but I really need to get to the thermal underwear section of my local outdoor shop before it closes…

Gear Review: Inov8 Skins Running Shoes (Part One)

Crikey. I’ve been reviewing running shoes for a while now, but I’ve never found myself quite as stumped about how to begin a review before.

That’s because not only are the Inov8 Skins quite unlike anything I’ve every run in before, they’ve also made my run a completely new experience; and quite frankly, I’m still in a mild state of shock.

So as you’ll note from the title of this post, I’ve decided to give myself a bit of wiggle room by recording my initial observations here, then following up with a second review in a week or two when I’ve decided how great/moderate/bad these things are. Though if I’m honest, having just got back from my first run in these things, and had an absolutely splendid time, I can’t see me saying too much that’s bad.

Anyhoo. As I’m not really sure what to say about the Inov8 Skins, let’s start at the beginning.

First impressions out of the box

Hhhmm. Ok. So I opened the box and basically took a couple of foot-shaped condoms out of the box. These things are soft, translucent and totally unlike anything I’ve ever seen before.

However, while I had planned this review to ring with lots of easy prophylactic jokes, there’s really not much to go on there. For starters, you’re never going to roll these babies on one-handed in the dark while your thoughts are elsewhere…

Nope, a certain amount of concentration and a bit of flexibility is required in order to fit the Inov8 Skins onto your feet, especially if you want to get all of your toes in the right order. Which is easier said than done, especially if you have toes that are quite as finger-like as mine.

However, once that’s done, and you’ve pressed the soft little stud things into the right holes, these things feel pretty soft and comfortable: albeit that they look extremely strange.

Things to consider before running

Worryingly, pre-run instructions are printed inside the box, where Inov8 urge you to introduce yourself slowly to running in their Skins.

So I wisely eschewed my plans for a 7 mile road run, and instead parked up at the beach for a slow 2-miler up and down a few sand dunes.

And what an absolute revelation they were! While I always enjoy a trail run, I can honestly say that I’ve never run up and down sand dunes quite as effortlessly in my life. My toes dug in just as nature intended, and it’s fair to say that there isn’t a running shoe on earth (in my humble opinion) that can make it so easy to deal with soft sand. That’s because while I’ve praised all sorts of trail shoes for their superb ‘forefoot flex’, running in the Inov8 Skins makes you realise just how inflexible all running shoes really are.

So much so that I totally forgot about starting off gently, and soon found myself four miles from the car and grinning broadly. Obviously, at my age, going back over four miles of steep dunes wasn’t really an option, so I chose a path called the Velvet Trail, which is a flat and very pleasing mixture of mud, moss and grass for my return leg.

Which is when I first discovered the small flaw in the Inov8 Skins as a trail shoe: they offer absolutely no more grip than your bare feet, causing me to slip-slide away for several hundred yards before I found a path that looked likely to take me to the shoreline.

As luck would have it, I got totally lost at this point, finding myself knee-deep in brambles and other thorny objects, causing mild panic and a few minutes of very tentative scrambling before I found myself on the hard-packed sand of the beach. yet, unbelievably, not a single thorn penetrated the silicone soles of my footwear (though to be honest, I ripped my legs to shreds).

After that, I had a gentle few miles along hard-packed sand and shallow seas to get back to the car; which was fairly enjoyable, though strangely more of an effort than running up and down the sand dunes.

The slightly confused verdict

These are about as far from standard running shoes as it’s possible to get. So I’m not even going to try to compare them to anything else. Lets just say that while I’ve scoffed openly at the whole barefoot running phenomenon in the past, I’m not laughing any more.

Nope, I’m sitting here thinking that all of my beach runs are going to involve the Inov8 Skins in future, as there really isn’t a trail shoe on earth that compares when you’re taking on sand dunes.

UPDATE: I woke up the next morning with very stiff calves, as one of the effects of these things is to stretch your calves and achilles slightly, as there is absolutely no heel lift. However, with subsequent runs, this has been minimised, and I’m still loving them as much as ever. Full review to follow next week. And I may yet wear these things for Hellrunner…